Friday, April 2, 2010

Holy Thursday

Evening Mass of the Lord's Supper

1 April 2010

Entrance For God so loved the world (mtgf)
Penitential Rite Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Gloria St Gabriels (mtgf)
Psalm 115 The blessing cup (mtgf)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Washing of the Feet Faith, hope and love(Christopher Walker)
Preparation of Gifts Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Eucharistic Acclamations No Greater Love (Michael Joncas)
Institution narrative (Michael Joncas)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion Call us to your table (Christopher Walker)
Procession Pange lingua (Ricky Manalo)
followed by plainchant Tantum ergo
Watching Lay down your head (John Bell)
Stay with me (Taizé)


I was very struck by a post on the Gotta Sing, Gotta Pray blog - Preparing the Triduum: Fighting the 'Disney Approach'. It's about building on last year and not changing much rather than what can we do 'bigger and better' this year. Change is evolutionary rather than radical. This means that both musicians and congregation are basically familiar with what is being sung and so helped to pray through their participation.

I am always surprised when putting the music out how much music is sung tonight. Some is drawn from our Lenten Sundays, some particular to this night, some, I fear, is musical indulgence. For Communion there is a wide range of possibilities. Call us to your table was possibly one of the indulgences. It was piece we had worked out and it was good to be able to do it with a rich texture of singers and instruments.

The significant change this year was the Procession to the Altar of Repose. Over the years we have sung: Pange lingua to the chant melody but in English; Our blessing cup (Bob Hurd) which though familiar did not seem to have been picked up. It was one of my reflections after last year's Triduum that this moment needed reconsideration. I remember using this as example of reflection and long term planning at a music day and mentioning I was looking at the Manalo setting and being encouraged by someone who was using it their parish. We made sure that musicians supported the procession - with instruments upstairs, piano in the crypt and the inevitable time differences. My impression was that people picked it up and sang it. There were a number factors that I think helped. The piece itself - an ostinato refrain is much easier to sing than a hymn, the pace seemed also to be about right. Above all, and I intend this as a compliment, it feels like Catholic schmaltz! It manages to seems to be one of those melodies you already knew. Liturgically the procession did not start until we had a full playthrough which may sound obvious but I think helped to link action and music rather than something the musicians while we are moving to the crypt.

I am aware this year of the forthcoming new translation of the Roman Missal and how that will affect our celebration of the Triduum. Will it require evolutionary or radical change?

My impression is that the new translation will not be in use until after Easter next year but by 2012 we will definitely be in new territory. So yes, prayers and people's texts will then have changed. Though I think this will be an opportunity to reflect on our choices once again in the light of the translation as, for example, both Faith, hope and love and Ubi caritas are adaptations of the current Missal texts they will continue to adaptions of the new texts.

What will change is the words of the Gloria and so the setting needs to be adapted or a new setting found. Perhaps most significant will be the Eucharistic Prayer. The Holy, holy is slightly different and the Memorial Acclamations are more so. I would hate to lose having part of Eucharistic Prayer sung as it adds to the solemnity of the occasion. There will be work to be done to continue this good practice.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Passion [Palm] Sunday

28 March 2010



Entrance Hosanna — Gathering (Paul Inwood)
Psalm 21 My God, My God (Christopher Walker)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Passion Acclamation Behold the Lamb of God (John Bell)
Preparation of Gifts Servant King (Graham Kendrick)
Eucharistic Acclamations Mass of Creation (Marty Haugen)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion Ours were the griefs (Stephen Dean)
Final My song is love unknown (Ireland)


Term has ended and so, as is usual, there is only one Sunday Mass. As we joined by members of the Music Group so adaptations had been made to what had originally been planned. It was great to have the extra people.

We do not have a procession — though we have the route, with even a chapel to start from, the number of steps outside the church would militate against it. We therefore follow the second option in the Missal, the Solemn Entrance. As the distances are not great we use the Hosanna and Benedictus from the Gathering Mass. We lose the richness and variety of the texts given in the Missal but gain a real sense of acclamation using a setting which people know by heart. It also, I hope, gives an extra depth to when we the sing the text in the Eucharistic Prayer.

In the proclamation of the Passion we sing a short acclamation. The Passion is read by four readers: narrator, Christ and two reading the others parts. The choir act as a crowd for a couple of lines. I have long seen the giving of parts to whole congregation as an example of 'false participation' — involvement for its own sake together with adding the air of a re-enactment. The use of acclamations to punctuate the narrative seem to be a more authentic response. As a rule such acclamation should be be just that — acclamations, short phrases rather than hymn verses and I favour a single text and just a few entries: less is more. Though I appreciate the idea of Delores Dufner's Acclamations in Cantate providing an appropriate text for each gospel writer in the end a familiar chant which all can again sing by heart Behold the Lamb of God.

Stephen Dean's Ours were the griefs he bore was this year's innovation replacing his setting of the Communion Antiphon Father, if this cup with its tangled chromaticism and suffering servant verses. I think I preferred the gentle, meditative setting of the canticle from 1 Peter, otherwise sung at Lent Sunday Evening Prayer. We sang it unaccompanied and it seemed to provide a moment of repose before the week ahead.

Monday, March 22, 2010

5th Sunday of Lent

21 March 2010

Entrance For God so loved the world (mtgf)
Penitential Rite Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Psalm 125 What marvels the Lord worked for us. (mtgf)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Preparation of Gifts The love of the Lord (Michael Joncas)
Eucharistic Acclamations Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion Remember not the sins of the past. (Bob Hurd)
Final Gift of love



Sunday, March 14, 2010

4th Sunday of Lent

14 March 2010

Entrance For God so loved the world (mtgf)
Penitential Rite Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Psalm 33 Taste and see. (Stephen Dean)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Preparation of Gifts Your love is finer (Marty Haugen)
Eucharistic Acclamations Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion You are mine (David Haas)
Final Praise my soul



Monday, March 8, 2010

3rd Sunday of Lent

25th Jubilee of Ordination to the Priesthood

7 March 2010


Entrance Gathered in the love (Marty Haugen)
Penitential Rite Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Psalm 102 The Lord is compassion and love (mtgf)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Preparation of Gifts Love one another (mtgf)
Eucharistic Acclamations Mass of Creation (Marty Haugen)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion Be still for the presence of the Lord (David Evans)
Holy Ground (mtgf)
Final Lord, you give the great commission (Jeffrey Rowthorn)


This Sunday we celebrated the Silver Jubilee of our Chaplain to the Priesthood with a single Mass at 4pm followed by Reception. Combining two Masses meant combining two groups of musicians which meant we had a greater richness of sound and musical possibilities. An underlying tension was celebrating a joyful occasion on a Sunday of Lent. We were faithful to the texts of the day though we looked at them through the 'lens' of ministry.

An example of the greater resources was the opening song. Marty Haugen based the song on the chords of the Pachelbel canon and provided a simplified version for the canon as an extended introduction. As we have some good instrumentalists, including 2 v g violinists, we did the original canon which was delightful. I am not always convinced by gathering music but this did, I think, provide some calm before the event. We were also able to use both piano and organ, with the other instruments, together. This seems to work find if it is clear which 'end' is leading. For Gathered in the Love the organ provided some extra bass. For the Mass of Creation, the Eucharistic Prayer was sung, organ led and the other instruments came in for the acclamations. It meant that the congregation was wrapped in sound.

With a number of visitors the local congregation, with the musicians, gave a good lead to the singing. Be still for the presence was chosen, in part, so that it would be a recognisable 'landmark'. Love one another was written for the celebration of the 150th anniversary of the College in 2000 which was in the Easter Season. John's image of 'bearing fruit' echoed Luke's gospel on this Sunday. Holy Ground was new for the occasion. The refrain picked up the image of standing on holy ground from the Exodus reading and idea of giving and receiving Christ as part of communion and ministry. I had originally wondered about psalm 14 for the verses but in the end chose a text on ministry from the Scottish Church Hymnary 4. A further consideration for the piece was that needed work well with musical resources, including guitars. At one stage I was concerned that it felt like two distinct pieces (refrain and verses) that had been bound together, and though the verses could work well as a separate hymn in the event it seemed to have a unity.

Sunday, February 28, 2010

2nd Sunday of Lent

28 February 2010

Entrance For God so loved the world (mtgf)
Penitential Rite Ubi Caritas (Bib Hurd)
Psalm 26 The Lord is my light and my help (mtgf)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Preparation of Gifts Eye has not seen (Marty Haugen)
Eucharistic Acclamations Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion Transfigure us, O Lord (Bob Hurd)
Final Be thou my vision


The Transfiguration seems to me to be a complex text. The use today is similar to the 4th Sunday of Advent when we hear the gospel of the Annunciation and the Visitation and there are also separate feasts for both events. It is big enough that we need to come at it twice. This year's readings suggest that the Transfiguration is a covenant - a pledge of future glory. The refrain of the Opening Song - For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son that everyone who believes in him shall have eternal life - can be understood as illuminating the Transfiguration. It is a key aspect of the Catholic use of scripture in the liturgy the juxtaposition of texts to provoke new understandings.


The Kyrie from the Ubi Caritas Mass to some extent challenges one of my 'blackspots' — can/should a Congregation respond with a different musical phrase rather than repeat what they have heard. To some extent as essentially the setting is repetitious A (sentence) B (cantor Kyrie); AB (all). It strikes me that a dialogue can have distinct musical phrases. A litany can more be one phrase sung by two different voices.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

1st Sunday of Lent

21 February 2010



Entrance For God so loved the world (mtgf)
Penitential Rite Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Psalm 91 Be with me Lord (Marty Haugen)
Gospel Acclamation Lenten (mtgf)
Preparation of Gifts Out of the Depths (Scott Soper)
Eucharistic Acclamations Ubi Caritas (Bob Hurd)
Lamb of God Mass of Remembrance (Marty Haugen)
Communion Out into the wilderness (Bob Hurd)
Final Guide me, O thou great Redeemer


The beginning of Lent sees one of the more dramatic changes in music for the Mass. For much the rest of year the changes are often staggered as one season connects with the next. With Lent change is starker. The Eucharistic Acclamations change for the first time since September. The Kyrie and, of course, the Gospel Acclamation are also different. It was noticeable as I animated the Holy, holy that people reached for their Mass sheet — that I was animating was also a sign that we were embarking on something new. Or at least give a refresher.

It is worth reflecting on what makes a piece memorable. Repetition is obviously one element. The memorability and distinctiveness of the melody will be another. It is also true to say that the more solemn (or unique) the occasion the more likely people are to remember settings — my experience is that people remember music from the Easter Triduum from year to year even if it is not used in between. The text can also play a part — the association of a melody with particular words.

This was the second time that we have used the Entrance Song For God so loved the world for the Sundays of Lent. Last year we sang it 5 times so I hope that there was a foundation to build on this morning. Though I think the refrain has a strong melody it does require a certain amount of conviction in its wide leaps — you can't sing it half heartedly.

For Communion the plan is to use for most of the Sundays settings from Bob Hurd's collection Lenten Journey. This skilfully recalls the readings from the context of Communion. My one quibble with collection is that it provides common settings for the first two Sundays because they share the same Gospel stories. My hunch is that each year is different and is shaped by the overarching themes of the Lectionary for that year. In year C we hear of the Temptations and the Transfiguration in the context of Covenant and Reconciliation. i.e. though there may be correspondences 'vertically' across the Sundays 1 and 2 the main thrust is horizontal through the season towards Easter.

Out of the Depths is a fine setting of Psalm 129 by Scott Soper. It is worth getting the octavo (rather than just the version in Laudate) for the, not difficult, choral parts.